Quadruple moderation is killing Lemmy. It’s a gift to Reddit
There’s a rule about online communities I want people here to understand: the 90-9-1 rule.
Roughly 90% lurk, 9% comment, and 1% create.
When I first got to Lemmy, I had trouble finding enough content I was interested in even commenting on. So I figured: why complain about the lack of content when I can start posting it myself?
That’s why I post so much.
If people don’t post, most Lemmy communities simply don’t have enough creators to sustain themselves. You need posts before lurkers can lurk, commenters can comment, and some of those people eventually become creators themselves.
I’m not posting just to flood Lemmy. I’m trying to help solve one of Lemmy’s biggest problems: not enough content creators.
And frankly, doing that has been a nightmare.
Lemmy has a quadruple-moderation problem
Every active content creator has to survive four layers:
- Community moderators can remove your posts or ban you from the community.
- Your home-instance admins can ban your entire account.
- Receiving-instance admins can block/ban you for everyone on their instance, even though you don’t belong to it.
- Public moderation history means those decisions follow you. One moderator’s decision can influence another and snowball into more moderation.
For prolific content creators, that’s brutal.
I’ve had multiple accounts banned over one or two posts that somebody didn’t like. Months of posting, comments, engagement and contributions can effectively disappear from a community because of a couple of moderation decisions.
And the more you contribute, the worse the odds become. If you make hundreds or thousands of posts, eventually you’re going to post something that one moderator somewhere doesn’t like.
You don’t need one moderation team to tolerate you. You need multiple independent moderators and admins, across multiple servers, to remain aligned indefinitely.
There’s almost no cost to deleting a creator
This is another major difference from Reddit.
There is generally no financial investment in a Lemmy community’s content. A volunteer moderator can ban someone who contributed months of posts and comments and lose all of that person’s future contributions without losing revenue, salary or investment.
The creator paid the cost in time.
The community loses the content.
The users lose something to read and discuss.
And the moderator who pushed the button may personally lose essentially nothing.
So who benefits from making prolific content creation this difficult?
Because it certainly isn’t Lemmy.
And this creates an enormous attack surface
I genuinely have trouble believing that everyone complaining about prolific posters simply doesn’t understand this dynamic. At some point I have to question whether some of it is deliberate.
If I were Reddit and wanted to undermine a federated competitor, this is exactly where I’d attack it: its content creators.
You don’t need to hack Lemmy. You don’t need to DDoS instances. You don’t need to take anything offline.
Lemmy already provides the mechanism.
Report prolific contributors. Call their posting “spam.” accuse them of being bots. Point moderators toward their public moderation histories. Get one account banned somewhere, then let that decision influence moderators elsewhere.
Eventually the creator gets tired of fighting and leaves.
I’m not claiming I have proof Reddit is doing this. I’m saying Lemmy’s architecture makes this kind of subversion ridiculously easy, and Reddit would be an obvious beneficiary.
Reddit doesn’t have this same federated quadruple-jeopardy problem. You’re primarily dealing with the moderation of the subreddit you’re contributing to.
Lemmy desperately needs more people creating content, yet its moderation structure makes life progressively harder for the people who create the most of it.
At some point we should be asking:
Who actually benefits from that?
Putting my thought on your original point at the top: “A plea to admins: protect your creators ban reddit agents instead”
All I can say is: Admins are already doing this to the best of their ability, for better or worse. Some admins moderate proportionally, some others don’t. It’s really a question of whether they appreciate your methods or not.
I also crosspost from Reddit, but specifically those that I would have posted/shared myself if I found it anywhere else.
A few other bots crosspost everything that goes in a subreddit in their own community. What do I see? Only the bots can post i.e. it’s a subreddit mirror. No one comments in it. In other words, it’s glorified spam that no one looks at. At best, it occupies space in lemmy instances. The reader is even required to go to Reddit to read the post itself. Knowing Lemmy, no one wants to bother doing that. Example: !pcmasterrace@zerobytes.monster. I see the new posts as a literal digital deluge that I can’t keep up with. I have better things to do.
I’m assuming here you want to populate Lemmy with a genuine desire to see it as a sustainable ecosystem. For general communities like the top communities you see in lemmy.world, the critical mass has already been reached. Force-increasing its monthly users will only do harm than good. Look up Eternal September to better understand where I’m coming from here.
What I suggest you can do is curate a small number of a subreddit’s best posts for the past 24 hours, copy its content, and crosspost them in an existing federated community. Consent from the community’s mods is important. Transparency (which includes posting as a bot account if this is automated) is also important. If your approach is unwanted by them, move on. That’s just how reality works. Also, respecting their decisions will do your reputation a favor and build trust in the long run.
Let people post content and the votes decide whats interesting and what not i’d say. Spam imo would be the same post over again.
Good idea, but it doesn’t work. People just go “haha funni joke, upvote” regardless of relevance. This is how communities get suffocated.
Plus, he’s specifically algorithmically selecting the posts that he thinks are going to get the most upvotes, regardless of their content. He doesn’t even look at the content. Of course they are going to get a lot of mindless upvotes, they’ve been tested in the upvote forge and found to have high engagement; but everyone knows that engagement is not a metric for humans, it’s a metric for advertisers, influencers, and manipulators. It doesn’t reflect the value, it reflects how aggressively it manipulates human quirks.
Engagement is a metric that trying to track user enjoyment, I want more engaging posts or even posts at this point on Lemmy.
edit: I am reposting from reddit - there is no rules against that. its actually great thing for majority of lemmy users!
As a member of the admin channels, this seems to be the most loathed part about your account. Reddit is a hatred echo chamber for the fediverse, second only to AI. While you view it as a positive element, nearly everyone else here left reddit and take offense to it’s posts following them. They view your participation to be bot-like behavior and that’s why you’re seeing so much pushback to your accounts in particular. I can promise you that a normal user that isn’t aggregating reddit content for the fediverse is not sharing your moderation and banning experience.
For a normal user, the gauntlet is much different. At least on the .zip domains, our policy is to not interfere with reports that don’t have a user or community that belongs to our instance unless it’s something requiring fast action like csam or doxxing, etc. We leave the rest to the mods and admins that the community belongs to.
Your account doesn’t offend me and I appreciate your participation but I will say that I’ve blocked you on my browsing account since I browse New/All and I don’t enjoy seeing what amounts to an overwhelming feed of reddit posts.
TL;DR: You’re using the fediverse in way that the majority of the platform feels it wasn’t designed for so you’re going to continue seeing the same retaliatory behaviors for as long as you continue to participate in that manner.
I appreciate the explanation, and honestly this “we dont want to be reddit” idea was brought up several times.
But I think there’s a fundamental disagreement here: not everyone shares your idea of what Lemmy should be. The existing 35k-ish MAU shouldn’t get to permanently define what Lemmy is allowed to become.
If the current philosophy were working, we’d see it in the results. Instead, Lemmy’s active user base has largely stagnated, and enormous numbers of communities are empty or get a couple of posts a week. Whatever we’re doing now isn’t producing meaningful growth.
And “we left Reddit” doesn’t necessarily mean “we never want to see anything that appeared on Reddit.” I left Reddit too. I wanted an alternative platform, not an alternative universe where interesting links, memes, news and discussions become contaminated because somebody also posted them on Reddit.
If my volume overwhelms New/All, that’s completely fair criticism. That’s something we can solve with posting limits, better filtering, community subscriptions, blocks, or better tooling.
But “the existing users don’t like this, therefore this isn’t what the Fediverse is for” becomes circular. The people who don’t like the existing culture may simply leave, so naturally the remaining population increasingly reflects that culture.
I’m trying a different approach because I want Lemmy to actually grow beyond its current niche. If most communities are empty and the active-user count isn’t meaningfully growing, I don’t think we should treat the status quo as proof that we’ve already figured out what users want.
And now you’re subjecting us to AI slop comments? Fuck all the way out of here with that shit. Use your own goddamn brain.
argue the points if you can.
When you make a point, I will. I’m not going to respond to slop.
I sign off on everything that was said.
But I think there’s a fundamental disagreement here: not everyone shares your idea of what Lemmy should be. The existing 35k-ish MAU shouldn’t get to permanently define what Lemmy is allowed to become.
I completely agree with you but until the community as a whole swings more toward wanting to feel like a Reddit part deux but without the algorithms, you’re going continue seeing this pushback and fighting an uphill battle. I wasn’t condoning the way your accounts are being treated. Lemmy and Piefed have a fairly robust blocking and filtering system. Your aggregation doesn’t affect my use of the platform at all because I’m able to hide it and I feel that’s enough protection, I don’t want to see your accounts reprimanded for behaving in a way that’s not breaking any rules that I can find.ike I said, I’m glad you’re here, regardless of whether I benefit from your posts or not. We need the variety to protect from these polarizing extremist mentalities towards behavior that doesn’t really effect us personally at all.
That being said, I am ok with stagnant growth metrics but I do understand that many users are not ok with that and desire for it’s popularity to explode. If it were ever to become as popular as reddit, I’m sure I would be looking for the next niche platform because I know in my heart that you can’t see that kind of popularity without the negative aspects that come along with it.
I’m able to hide it and I feel that’s enough protection.
“Why should I change it? He’s the one that sucks.”
New users shouldn’t have to start their experience by blocking a bunch of accounts.
They don’t. As I said, I browse New/All and it’s a niche platform. I’ve been a new user, and as very few people browse the way I do, for the most common method of browsing, simply creating your sub list and blocking a very few accounts that don’t align with your desirable feed is more than enough effort to keep from seeing anything you don’t want to.
You literally just repost from reddit. You arent the first person to do it, you won’t be the last, but it doesn’t actually make the fediverse look more active, it makes it look like a bot-filled ghost town.
Yeah I’m testing new reposting tool. Why
- sanitation@lemmy.radio
This reposting tool is open source - im not hiding the fact im reposting from reddit, never did as you discovered.
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/lemmy-deep-lighthouse/
I encourage more people to use it and populate lemmy communities with content.
using automation is not against lemmy.world rules. There is a real person clicking the button and reading all ofthe responses. I just can post posts Im interested in much much quicker - that should not be a problem, thats a good thing.

It’s really just that easy.
feeling is mutual
You can reply to replies. You don’t need multiple top-level comments.
After blocking I didn’t have access to any of the leaf discussion nodes. I suppose I could have replied to myself. Terribly sorry.
let’s post moar \o/
Ah the tired old thing we need the fediverese like x.
Mastodon tried to do it. now you with lemmy.
people on fediverse doesn’t want cross posted stuff. They want stuff from actual people and those poster interacting with the post.
This moderation you are upset about isn’t as much of a problem.
You are trying to speed run reddit here and it isn’t going to work. Just work with what lemmy offers and eventually people will come but it is going to take time.
But “eventually people will come” is exactly the assumption I’m challenging.
Lemmy has been around for years. Hundreds of thousands of accounts have been registered, yet MAU is still tiny and countless communities are barely active. At what point does “just give it time” stop being a strategy?
And again, who is “people on the Fediverse”? The people who are still here? Of course the current users disproportionately like the current culture. The people who tried it and left aren’t here to tell you what they wanted and thats 95% of users - they are not here anymore
I’m not trying to speedrun Reddit. I’m trying to solve a very basic chicken-and-egg problem: people want human conversations, but conversations need something to start them.
If organic posting alone isn’t producing enough of that, I don’t see anything sacred about waiting another five years and hoping it suddenly does.
what chicken and egg problem. we have the eggs we are just waiting on them to hatch.
You talk about how many accounts are here like some techbro that wants to line go up. It isn’t going to happen. It took linux years to get where for people to see as a solution for their everyday computer and still more edge cases that need to be solve.
you can’t solve everything by cloning a product, you been seen as an inferior especially if you cross post stuff from another social network.
organic is the only way to get things working to attract people that is the unfortunate about these things.
The Linux analogy proves my point. Linux didn’t sit around waiting for the eggs to hatch. People identified barriers and aggressively fixed them.
Drivers sucked? Fix them. Gaming sucked? Build Proton. Installation sucked? Make it easier.
And let’s not pretend Linux grew purely “organically.” Billions of dollars and enormous amounts of engineering have been poured into Linux by IBM, Red Hat, Intel, Google, Microsoft, Valve, and plenty of other corporations.
Lemmy has empty communities and poor retention. So fix the problems.
“Organic is the only way” isn’t a law of nature. It’s a strategy. And after years of stagnant MAU, we’re allowed to question whether that strategy is working.
I don’t want line-go-up. I want critical mass so communities aren’t fucking empty.
Still took linux years. You sound like it needs to happen yesterday.
Cross posts isn’t the answer. People see that as an dead community.
I think you’re completely confusing the barriers to entry.
Linux had to overcome hardware compatibility, drivers, software availability, installation complexity, gaming support, OEM deals, and decades of Windows dominance. And even after billions in corporate investment, desktop Linux still isn’t mainstream.
Lemmy is a fucking website. Click a link, make an account, start using it. The barrier isn’t remotely comparable.
Getting Lemmy from 35k MAU to meaningful critical mass should be infinitely easier than getting people to replace their entire operating system.
And an empty community looks a hell of a lot more dead to me than one with relevant posts waiting for people to discuss them.
Took years
A community with just post and only one person posting everyday is more dead than an empty one
You’re ignoring the 99% of people who consume far more than they create.
An empty community gives them nothing. A community with one person consistently posting relevant content gives lurkers something to read, vote on, and eventually comment on.
Will one poster make a thriving community? Obviously not. But you need something there before the other 99% have anything to engage with.
“Keep it empty until organic posters magically arrive” is how communities stay empty.
Flooding “Lemmy” with reposts from Reddit will make “Lemmy” look like a “tardy clone of Reddit with less discussion”. Why stick with a repost platform if you can get the same content but more and earlier with Reddit? New Reddit frontend still remains browsable without login (maybe with some irritation, but anyway).
One has to act differently. To get to the sources first (or, at least before Reddit, at least sometimes). RSS feeds of publications (already worked on in PieFed), microblogging support: compatibility with Mastodon (available on MBin and now on PieFed), already existing bot comms reposting from Hacker News and Lobste.rs (both these sites have no subs and crossposting to a comm may have sense…), reposting e.g. art from Mastodon, Bluesky, cara.app…
I actually agree with most of that. Those are good ideas. Do all of them.
Pull from RSS, Mastodon, Bluesky, Hacker News, Lobsters, original sources, and Reddit. These aren’t mutually exclusive.
Where I disagree is treating Reddit as uniquely contaminated. If Reddit happens to surface a great article, meme, video, or discussion before we find it elsewhere, I don’t see why Lemmy should refuse it on principle.
And the goal isn’t to permanently make Lemmy a delayed Reddit feed. It’s to bootstrap communities while building exactly the ecosystem you’re describing.
Eventually I’d love for the flow to reverse: interesting stuff originates on Lemmy and gets reposted to Reddit.
Did you know all creator posts are wiped out from lemmy after account banned?
I’m dubious of that, because I’ve often seen posts with a red [banned from community] tag right beside the user, which often made me scratch my head - how/why is that post there if the user is banned?
Another thing to keep in mind, we don’t need to be reddit in terms of content volume. Yeah, a lot of us expect that, but it’s better for us, as humans in the long term, to be slower here
Its optional, you can ban and remove, or just ban. Up to the admin.
I’ve always wondered, because sometimes it looked like that, despite being banned, a certain account still made new posts to the community they were banned from
community ban dont remove conent.
instance ban in addition - removes all content. I’ve had thousnds of posts wiped out that way.
I’ve got my own gripes about Lemmy but moderation is not one of them.
Reddit has a massive problem with overzealous moderation and content being modded simply because one individual mod doesn’t like or disagrees with it. Haven’t noticed any of that on Lemmy.
And I disagree that moderation is preventing Lemmy from achieving critical mass. Its gotten this far with its mod system. It feels way better populated than even a year ago. It will never have the commercial reach Reddit has but I’ve no doubt it will continue to grow.
“It feels way better populated” isn’t the same thing as actually growing.
That’s the part I keep coming back to. Lemmy’s MAU has been hovering around the same relatively small level for months now. actually down from a year ago YOY. lemmy is contracting.
https://lemmy.fediverse.observer/stats
^ its an objective fact based on raw numbers lemmy so nicely provides. we are down 2k MAU year over year.The current stats literally track monthly active users, and we’re still talking about roughly tens of thousands of people, not sustained breakout growth.
And the wider Fediverse has the same retention problem: FediDB currently shows 14 million total accounts but only about 1.17 million monthly active users.
So maybe your personal moderation experience has been great. That’s completely valid. Mine hasn’t.
But “it got this far” isn’t evidence that the strategy is working. If the goal is critical mass, years of stagnation and mostly empty communities are evidence that something isn’t working.
I agree that stagnation is a problem, but you’re comparing Lemmy’s growth with that of multi-billion dollar platforms with ridiculous marketing budgets and fully staffed marketing teams. That’s unfair (and unrealistic) because Lemmy is a community project that has to grow on word-of-mouth alone. It will grow much slower and with periods of stagnation because that’s the nature of the beast. And if there’s stagnantion that’s our fault for not shouting loud enough.
Also, you’re taking your negative experience and trying to pin that to user growth. I can see your point but I disagree that moderation is a major factor.
But that’s exactly why I’m proposing a solution that doesn’t require a billion-dollar marketing budget.
Reddit is doing plenty of negative marketing for itself. People are already frustrated with the platform, moderation, API changes, ads, corporate decisions, etc. Lemmy doesn’t need to manufacture that dissatisfaction or outspend Reddit. The potential users are already looking for alternatives.
The problem is what happens when they arrive.
If they open Lemmy and find inactive communities and little content around their interests, word of mouth isn’t going to fix that. They leave.
I’m proposing a way to bootstrap those communities with relevant content, give people something to discuss, and hopefully turn some of those lurkers into commenters and eventually native posters.
Maybe moderation isn’t the main cause of stagnation. I’m open to that. But “we just need to shout louder” won’t help if people arrive and don’t find enough reason to stay.
Ok but… You’re not creating. You’re flooding Lemmy with garbage from reddit. None of what you post is your creation. And it’s all low quality reddit crap. In !workreform@lemmy.world, for example, it was a fairly slow community, which is fine. Then you started flooding it with low-effort memes, drowning out the useful posts. This will kill a community. “Then post the content you want to see”, you’ll say. But there’s no point when for every one useful post there are thirty trash memes pushing it down.
Your actions are actively harmful to Lemmy.
I post into workreform - because I support that community and its message an find those memes very very relevant.
its not crap. all that stuff then reaching frontpage on lemmy is quite telling. those posts reach 1k upvotes as well. This is a proof those posts are well received.@frontg - you have 4 Posts in a year. you are the reason that people like me have to create more content the way I do it. if you would to contribute more I wouldnt have to.
@frontg - you have 4 Posts in a year. you are the reason that people like me have to create more content the way I do it.
OK, that takes the cake. Fuck your hubris.
Upvotes are not a measure of value. That thought process is how you get reddit and Facebook.
Again, you aren’t creating. You’re slopping reddit’s garbage over to Lemmy and suffocating its communities.
That thought process is how you get reddit and Facebook
but many people want that. Thats what I want - independent uncensorable reddit.
the fact that lemmy is not growing is confirming that current lemmy content approach is not working . proof is in the puddingYou WANT to turn lemmy into reddit? Fuck, now I’ve heard it all. Every comment you make just makes it worse. Everyone here is trying to get away from reddit. Christ.
You WANT to turn lemmy into reddit? Fuck, now I’ve heard it all. Every comment you make just makes it worse. Everyone here is trying to get away from reddit. Christ.
me too - I hate reddit, been banned so many times. doesnt mean that we should not be able to share content from other networks. we should do it until lemmy can craete own organic content.
your response is just pure naivity and ignores hard lemmy MAU numbers
Consent should matter though?
Also, a poster of OC is a “content creator”, but just offering links isn’t really “creating” anything really, just spreading it around?
Kudos for trying to help. If you listen first before speaking then you may find your messages received better.
If you start your own instance, then no mods or admins can stop you from posting whatever you want. Even CSAM.
Though consent really should matter, and others could defederate from your instance if they wanted.
Mods are never going to change. Think what you could do differently to enjoy your time here better, and encourage people to like your posts more. e.g. label your account as a bot, and/or make a separate alt account for your human interactions, to allow people to recognize (and even block) based on the bot label if they want to? A bot that is properly labeled is no issue at all, it’s the lack of transparency that gets people upset when it seems one way and then they get disappointed at finding that it is something else. If you are empathetic to others’ sensitivities then obviously you would be better received? It’s more work for you, but far less than the cumulative efforts of all people who end up having to catch you individually.
You have a right to speak, but nobody owes you a platform, nor should others be forced to listen. The consent of the governed should matter! And it will, one way or another.
Someone can create their own instance?
Also: not all moderators follow the same moderation style. When the Tesseract block list leaked, most Lemmings took it as a badge of honour. I was on it as well :3
yeah - but if every active postere then is forced to create their own lemmy instance because the are forced out - I think thats a problem.
Not every active poster, just serial bot posters and those who use AI to post. Which is good the less of you in the central fediverse the better.
Lemmy: ~756,000 registered, ~35,000 MAU.
ill leave you at this. no - lemmy is not better. its a skeleton of what it can be
its a skeleton of what it can be
You talk like a c suite wanna be. Must be in the frequent AI use.
I don’t know if the LLM you run everything by told you that’s a compelling argument or not, but it isn’t. Valuing numbers is what led to reddit being a shit hole. All of which have nothing to do with serial bot posting or using AI to post.
This, a hundred times this. Chasing big numbers like posts totals, upvotes, MAUs is what ruins communities. Slow the fuck down! Make communities for people, not bots and investors!
You can make fun of the “C-suite” language, but retention and growth aren’t imaginary concepts invented by Reddit executives. They’re how you tell whether people actually want to keep using something.
I think Lemmy has enormous potential. That’s precisely why I’m arguing about this instead of just leaving.
I doubt you’ve made multiple profitable businesses if you can’t even make your own arguments and just copy paste LLM output between comments. Not that it matters if it is somehow true.
Prioritising growth is practically antithetical to decentralisation and the fediverse in general. If the growth takes longer, so be it. Lemmy has grown in the relatively short time I’ve been here. Noticeably so and a majority done without shitty bot posting and AI posting. People who join here typically hate that shit and the glorious algorithm TM. Again you’re attempting to conflate the growth/health of Lemmy with serial bot posting and AI posting. The former does not require the latter. The majority of internet sites grew without the latter. The majority of people here don’t like the latter and don’t think the former is worth it. No amount of jank LLM output, because to you’ve had to make it argue your perspective for you, will change that. Anyway I’ve not going to waste further time on this with someone too lazy to formulate and type their own response.
I’ve built several web businesses that actually make money, so yes, I tend to look at things through the lens of whether a product is working and what trajectory it’s on.
And from that perspective, Lemmy right now feels like a skeleton of what it could be. That’s not “valuing numbers above everything.” It’s recognizing that hundreds of thousands of people have tried it, MAU remains tiny, and huge numbers of communities are barely alive.
You can make fun of the “C-suite” language, but retention and growth aren’t imaginary concepts invented by Reddit executives. They’re how you tell whether people actually want to keep using something.
I think Lemmy has enormous potential. That’s precisely why I’m arguing about this instead of just leaving.
Well, despite how slimy and disgusting everything you just said is, your position, and best future actions for you to achieve your goals, are pretty clear cut.
Start your own instance, and try to make it grow. You apparently have the experience, so go ahead.
Don’t you dare complain about people’s ability to defederate with you again, because it will start to sound like what you want, is to force people to consume what you decide to upload, and that’s authoritarian.
Do your best, since you know so well, and attract the people who agree with you.
slimeball reporting for duty question - do they defederate just one community or entire instance? because it sounds to me its entire instance and thats another dumb thing about lemmy.
STFU and go back to Reddit. You don’t even curate the shit you post. You’re a fire hose of raw sewage and I truly, truly wish you would fuck off.
STFU and go back to Reddit. You don’t even curate the shit you post. You’re a fire hose of raw sewage and I truly, truly wish you would fuck off.
That’s simply not true. There are multiple layers of curation before anything gets posted.
Posts have to meet score thresholds, age limits, duplicate checks, community-specific rules, content filters, and AI-assisted moderation. It’s specifically designed not to blindly mirror Reddit.
You can argue that my filters aren’t strict enough or that the volume is too high. Those are legitimate criticisms.
But saying “you aren’t even fucking curating” is just factually wrong.
0 posts in 3 years - you are the problem
dipshit, you are the reddit leaking into lemmy
None of the curation comes from you. The entire curation is done by Reddit users and bots
nono - thats actually curation on my side, on top of curation on reddit.
my reposting implements AI curation and other stuff
Bruh, calling yourself a creator for reposting shit other people also found and reposted to a different site is the equivalent of calling yourself an artist while using genAI. 🙄
do we need a never slop meme here?

Given their profile avatar is AI-generated, well…
This post was written by AI
And now they’ve switched to posting comments generated by AI.
They are even using AI just to repost …
[…] have to be be recent (no more than 2 days), not have duplicates on lemmy, there are AI rules I typically add to enforce adherance with community rules etc. its only a high quailty highly rationed content.
im actually putting my money where my mouth is. credits are not cheap.
You can fight AI all you want, but that ship has sailed. AI is already embedded in search, moderation, coding, translation, recommendation systems, spam detection, and content workflows across the internet.
I’m using it here as a filtering and moderation tool - checking community rules, duplicates, age, relevance, and other criteria before something gets posted. That’s almost the opposite of blindly dumping content.
You can dislike AI on principle, but “AI was involved” isn’t an argument that the resulting post is bad. Judge the content and whether it follows the community’s rules.
Yeah and everything is worse because of it now, so take your clanker simping somewhere else. It will gain you no sympathy here. Then again, this entire posts makes it quite clear you don’t seem to have any ability to read the room.
Then again, this entire posts makes it quite clear you don’t seem to have any ability to read the room.
Assuming they even read their own post.
“Read the room” is exactly the mentality I’m questioning.
The room is 35k MAU and stagnant. Maybe optimizing everything around the preferences of the people already in the room is part of why nobody new is walking through the door.
And “everything is worse because of AI” isn’t an argument. It’s an opinion. I’m using AI as a tool for filtering, moderation, and automation. Judge the results.
If Lemmy only welcomes people who already agree with the existing culture on AI, content, reposting, and what the Fediverse is supposed to be, don’t be surprised when it remains a tiny echo chamber. and at the moment - its exactly what it is - a tiny 35k MAU stagnant echo chamber
The room is 35k MAU and stagnant.

lots of people. thats why lemmy is 35K mau stagnant
AI generated comment
I was starting to wonder because of your lengthy posts and use of emphasis, did you use AI to make this post?
Uploading AI slop and posting genuine content (reposted or “spammy” or not) are two very, very different things.
im running out of time. genuinely tried to make this work but I Think lemmy is just going to stay tiny reddit controlled app
Running out of time, or tokens?
time. thats another thing im arguing - having to relitigate all the same things time and time again is exhausting and time consuming.
I guess thats another reason people just quit posting.
I suspect most of it is reddit agents however
It’s not a matter of quality, but of effort.
Nobody needs you to prompt an AI and post the results. If we wanted AI generated bullshit, we could generate it ourselves without your dumb ass.
You have no skill. You have no talent. You have nothing of value to offer what-so-ever of yourself. But now you have a device that lets you cosplay as someone who has those things, and you act like you are contributing when you’re really not.
Fuck off, cogsucker.
You’re proving my point. The overwhelming majority of content on social platforms is sharing, linking, commenting on, or remixing content created somewhere else. That’s how aggregation sites work.
Reddit didn’t become Reddit because millions of users were producing original investigative journalism, memes, videos, and research. People found interesting shit and submitted it so everyone else had something to discuss.
Call it “posting,” “submitting,” or “curating” instead of “creating” if the word creator bothers you. The point doesn’t change: someone still has to find and post the content.
If nobody does that, your feed is empty.
I’d rather a feed that updates twice a day but everything is on-topic and worthwhile than one where I have to sift through reposts and screenshots to find those two worthwhile posts.
This comment is correct despite the unpopularity.
There is a difference between organically reposting memes you come across and setting up a bot to sync two newsfeed.
I agree. That doesn’t mean that particular comment is incorrect.
But it’s not a blind feed sync. That’s the important distinction.
There are filters for upvote thresholds, post age, community-specific rules, content requirements, and AI-assisted moderation before anything gets posted.
The end result is essentially the same content I would have selected and posted manually. I’ve just automated the repetitive work of finding, filtering, checking, and submitting it.
Automation changes the amount of manual effort required, not the intent or selection criteria. in fact lemmy.world specifically has a rule allowing automation.
You can disagree with my thresholds or posting volume, but calling it “syncing two newsfeeds” makes it sound like I’m blindly mirroring Reddit. I’m automating the curation I would otherwise be doing by hand.
It’s correct only when you think quantity is everything and quality doesn’t matter. Do you think someone posting into a community because they think that community might like it is the same as copy pasting every post from one community into another community?
I think most people on lemmy/Piefed prefer quality over quantity.
No, the entire comment on it’s own is correct. Most content on social media is from people sharing, linking, commenting on, or remixing content found somewhere else.
The comment doesn’t say anything about quality vs quantity. They’re only talking about the state of social media and how it is built up.
My personal opinion on sanitation’s contributions is that a lot of it is spam. I’d prefer to have people manually reposting instead of this bot-like action of reposting a lot of stuff automatically, it can make communities feel empty. But all of that is aside from the comment I replied to which is ultimately correct about social media.
I’ll clarify a bit because I think I didn’t do a good job before. The meat of places like Reddit or Lemmy isn’t the posts. If posts were all we care about everyone would be using RSS instead. The meat is in the comment section, the discussion the post generates. That’s where most of the new content lives, unless you want to argue that you have no original thoughts and the comment you made is some remixed content from somewhere else. So OP is correct that posts are usually people remixing content found elsewhere, but posts themselves are not how sites like this live. The post is just the bone for the meat to stick to, something to focus discussion. He is wrong in the sense that he’s putting the focus on posts and essentially saying “If posts exists, discussions will happen”. But the focus should on the discussions and posts serve the purpose of focusing discussion.
And that’s where the quality vs quantity point comes in because there are two ways to create these sources of discussion. The first the quantity approach, which is what sanitation is doing it, by slinging shit at the wall and seeing what sticks. Eventually 1 in a 100 posts becomes a point of discussion. The other is the quality approach. Instead of automating away posting shit you do it manually. You find something you want to share and then you take the time to make a post. The manual labor does something that automation can’t, it puts a human element into the post. It puts intentionality into it because you are choosing to post it in the place you think best suits for that post and you’re personally invested in that post which means you’re open to engage with the discussions that might happen because of this post. Automation gets rid of both of those things and actually makes it worse because it fills feeds with posts that have no human element to it. It drowns out actually interesting posts. That’s actually part of my criticism of Reddit comment section because at some point Reddit comment section became flooded with low effort one-liner comments designed to get as many upvotes as possible and those low effort comments drowned out interesting threads so your ability to have meaningful conversations actually dwindled even though the overall amount of “conversations” increased. The same thing happens with posts which is why we both agree that sanitation is doing is spam. It drowns out interesting posts by filling the feed with uninteresting posts and nobody wants to shift through shit to find something interesting.















