Quadruple moderation is killing Lemmy. It’s a gift to Reddit

There’s a rule about online communities I want people here to understand: the 90-9-1 rule.

Roughly 90% lurk, 9% comment, and 1% create.

When I first got to Lemmy, I had trouble finding enough content I was interested in even commenting on. So I figured: why complain about the lack of content when I can start posting it myself?

That’s why I post so much.

If people don’t post, most Lemmy communities simply don’t have enough creators to sustain themselves. You need posts before lurkers can lurk, commenters can comment, and some of those people eventually become creators themselves.

I’m not posting just to flood Lemmy. I’m trying to help solve one of Lemmy’s biggest problems: not enough content creators.

And frankly, doing that has been a nightmare.

Lemmy has a quadruple-moderation problem

Every active content creator has to survive four layers:

  1. Community moderators can remove your posts or ban you from the community.
  2. Your home-instance admins can ban your entire account.
  3. Receiving-instance admins can block/ban you for everyone on their instance, even though you don’t belong to it.
  4. Public moderation history means those decisions follow you. One moderator’s decision can influence another and snowball into more moderation.

For prolific content creators, that’s brutal.

I’ve had multiple accounts banned over one or two posts that somebody didn’t like. Months of posting, comments, engagement and contributions can effectively disappear from a community because of a couple of moderation decisions.

And the more you contribute, the worse the odds become. If you make hundreds or thousands of posts, eventually you’re going to post something that one moderator somewhere doesn’t like.

You don’t need one moderation team to tolerate you. You need multiple independent moderators and admins, across multiple servers, to remain aligned indefinitely.

There’s almost no cost to deleting a creator

This is another major difference from Reddit.

There is generally no financial investment in a Lemmy community’s content. A volunteer moderator can ban someone who contributed months of posts and comments and lose all of that person’s future contributions without losing revenue, salary or investment.

The creator paid the cost in time.

The community loses the content.

The users lose something to read and discuss.

And the moderator who pushed the button may personally lose essentially nothing.

So who benefits from making prolific content creation this difficult?

Because it certainly isn’t Lemmy.

And this creates an enormous attack surface

I genuinely have trouble believing that everyone complaining about prolific posters simply doesn’t understand this dynamic. At some point I have to question whether some of it is deliberate.

If I were Reddit and wanted to undermine a federated competitor, this is exactly where I’d attack it: its content creators.

You don’t need to hack Lemmy. You don’t need to DDoS instances. You don’t need to take anything offline.

Lemmy already provides the mechanism.

Report prolific contributors. Call their posting “spam.” accuse them of being bots. Point moderators toward their public moderation histories. Get one account banned somewhere, then let that decision influence moderators elsewhere.

Eventually the creator gets tired of fighting and leaves.

I’m not claiming I have proof Reddit is doing this. I’m saying Lemmy’s architecture makes this kind of subversion ridiculously easy, and Reddit would be an obvious beneficiary.

Reddit doesn’t have this same federated quadruple-jeopardy problem. You’re primarily dealing with the moderation of the subreddit you’re contributing to.

Lemmy desperately needs more people creating content, yet its moderation structure makes life progressively harder for the people who create the most of it.

At some point we should be asking:

Who actually benefits from that?

  • birdwing@lemmy.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    3 months ago

    Someone can create their own instance?

    Also: not all moderators follow the same moderation style. When the Tesseract block list leaked, most Lemmings took it as a badge of honour. I was on it as well :3

    • sanitation@lemmy.todayOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      3 months ago

      yeah - but if every active postere then is forced to create their own lemmy instance because the are forced out - I think thats a problem.

      • CTDummy@piefed.social
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        3 months ago

        Not every active poster, just serial bot posters and those who use AI to post. Which is good the less of you in the central fediverse the better.

        • sanitation@lemmy.todayOP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          3 months ago

          Lemmy: ~756,000 registered, ~35,000 MAU.

          ill leave you at this. no - lemmy is not better. its a skeleton of what it can be

          • CTDummy@piefed.social
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            3 months ago

            its a skeleton of what it can be

            You talk like a c suite wanna be. Must be in the frequent AI use.

            I don’t know if the LLM you run everything by told you that’s a compelling argument or not, but it isn’t. Valuing numbers is what led to reddit being a shit hole. All of which have nothing to do with serial bot posting or using AI to post.

            • sanitation@lemmy.todayOP
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              0
              ·
              3 months ago

              I’ve built several web businesses that actually make money, so yes, I tend to look at things through the lens of whether a product is working and what trajectory it’s on.

              And from that perspective, Lemmy right now feels like a skeleton of what it could be. That’s not “valuing numbers above everything.” It’s recognizing that hundreds of thousands of people have tried it, MAU remains tiny, and huge numbers of communities are barely alive.

              You can make fun of the “C-suite” language, but retention and growth aren’t imaginary concepts invented by Reddit executives. They’re how you tell whether people actually want to keep using something.

              I think Lemmy has enormous potential. That’s precisely why I’m arguing about this instead of just leaving.

              • Hugucinogens@lemmy.blahaj.zone
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                0
                ·
                3 months ago

                Well, despite how slimy and disgusting everything you just said is, your position, and best future actions for you to achieve your goals, are pretty clear cut.

                Start your own instance, and try to make it grow. You apparently have the experience, so go ahead.

                Don’t you dare complain about people’s ability to defederate with you again, because it will start to sound like what you want, is to force people to consume what you decide to upload, and that’s authoritarian.

                Do your best, since you know so well, and attract the people who agree with you.

                • sanitation@lemmy.todayOP
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  0
                  ·
                  3 months ago

                  slimeball reporting for duty question - do they defederate just one community or entire instance? because it sounds to me its entire instance and thats another dumb thing about lemmy.

                  • Hugucinogens@lemmy.blahaj.zone
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    0
                    ·
                    edit-2
                    3 months ago

                    Yep, entire instance. Don’t worry about that though, the difference between Lemmy and the real world, is that anyone, can make an account anywhere, so the people that actually want to see your instance, are not going to stay in an instance that defederates you.

                    Each single instance, has its own defederation list, basically a block list. Defederation, is only for the single instance that decides to block yours, meanwhile literally everyone else except that instance interacts with you normally.

                    On top of that, Defederation is only one way, which means you can still see their content! Your interactions are just hidden from their users. Those users, are users that (under normal circumstances) know about the defederation, and choose to remain in that instance. On top of that, they also choose not to make a second account in yours, for example.

                    (Personally, when I wanted to see an instance that mine had defederated from, I just made a second account in that instance. Lemmy clients make having multiple accounts, and switching between them, really, really easy).

                    People have the freedom, and the ability, to choose who they want to interact with, here. Enjoy it, find your people.

                    I honestly really wish you luck, and hope you create a part of Lemmy, that is missing right now.

                    I like meme-dumps, I use discord for that explicit purpose (meme-dump servers). I just don’t want the good community driven culture of Lemmy, to be sacrificed for that.

                    Help Lemmy have both.

                    (For the record, I really respect the honesty that you’re facing this whole issue with. I really do wish you the best, and hope you succeed, if you try.)

            • frongt@lemmy.zip
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              0
              ·
              3 months ago

              This, a hundred times this. Chasing big numbers like posts totals, upvotes, MAUs is what ruins communities. Slow the fuck down! Make communities for people, not bots and investors!

              • sanitation@lemmy.todayOP
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                0
                ·
                3 months ago

                You can make fun of the “C-suite” language, but retention and growth aren’t imaginary concepts invented by Reddit executives. They’re how you tell whether people actually want to keep using something.

                I think Lemmy has enormous potential. That’s precisely why I’m arguing about this instead of just leaving.

                • CTDummy@piefed.social
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  0
                  ·
                  3 months ago

                  I doubt you’ve made multiple profitable businesses if you can’t even make your own arguments and just copy paste LLM output between comments. Not that it matters if it is somehow true.

                  Prioritising growth is practically antithetical to decentralisation and the fediverse in general. If the growth takes longer, so be it. Lemmy has grown in the relatively short time I’ve been here. Noticeably so and a majority done without shitty bot posting and AI posting. People who join here typically hate that shit and the glorious algorithm TM. Again you’re attempting to conflate the growth/health of Lemmy with serial bot posting and AI posting. The former does not require the latter. The majority of internet sites grew without the latter. The majority of people here don’t like the latter and don’t think the former is worth it. No amount of jank LLM output, because to you’ve had to make it argue your perspective for you, will change that. Anyway I’ve not going to waste further time on this with someone too lazy to formulate and type their own response.

                  • sanitation@lemmy.todayOP
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    0
                    ·
                    3 months ago

                    The irony is that you’re arguing decentralization requires accepting slow growth, when decentralization says absolutely nothing about growth rate.

                    And “Lemmy has noticeably grown” is anecdotal. MAU is measurable. If the numbers are stagnant, saying it feels busier doesn’t change the trajectory.

                    I’m also not claiming automation is the only way Lemmy can grow. I’m saying it’s one tool for solving the empty-community problem. If you have a better scalable way to get thousands of mostly dead communities active, great. Build it.

                    As for AI, yes, I use it. I also write software to automate repetitive work. That’s kind of the point of software.

                    Attacking the tool I used to phrase an argument is a lot easier than addressing the argument.