It happened. No matter how long ago, a person’s life was ruined. That person was seriously hurt, probably even physically, but definitely mentally…and those scars fucking stay. So, it shouldn’t matter how long ago it happened…just that it did happen.


I do, otherwise it’s just wanton punishment for the sake of punishment. I believe in harm reduction, not harm multiplication, so if there is no benefit to the people involved or society and we’re still choosing punishment I generally disagree with punishment simply for the sake of punishment.
so for you it’s enough if a criminal “cured” from his desire to do crime, no punishment needed? And as I said for myself: certainly not /just/ punishment, but also…
Actually yes, I do feel this way. You stated it exactly.
If we had a psycho pass system that could, with 100% certainty, confirm that a criminal will never commit any crimes again (ethical crimes, not necessarily legal crimes), I would say yes. The problem is that such a system doesn’t exist and it’s highly likely that criminals will be repeat offenders, so we have to “guess” that they are rehabilitated after the punishment.
I don’t think revenge punishment should exist in a just society, only harm minimisation. The punishment needs to be either a deterrent, rehabilitation tool, or harm containment tool, not revenge.
if someone kills one I love, I fear I’d have the need to see them suffer. Surely, I’d personally punish harder in this case, but the law should find a balance here.
Anyway, as you say: we don’t have that system, so we are just discussing the reasons for jail time, not the the if.