College group projects, in my experience, are a terrible idea because all the ones I was forced to do never had any kind of accountability mechanism. If some slacker didn’t pull their weight, the rest of the group just had to shrug and soldier on.
In the real world, group projects are different because there’s a hierarchy. The group leader has some disciplinary capacity, so if someone doesn’t carry weight, there can be actual consequences.
If the point of a group project is to learn how to collaborate, groups should be random and scores should be individual. That’s what would happen at work too.
If it’s a workshop for fun then sure, people can go with their friends.
Yeahhh finding a homework group every semester is such. a. pain. Luckily I always find some people I jive a bunch with
“Hey guys, you mind if I join your group?”
“Ewwww, NO!! You smell like you soak your clothes in rotting cabbage every night and why is your face bleeding?”
The answer will most likely be in between these. Probably closer to OK.
Learning how to integrate into groups is a crucial part of college (and high school) because the point is educating you how to be a functioning member of society. Almost every aspect of that includes working with others, it’s a skill you need to practice and be comfortable with.
I will continue to argue that grades k-12 the education is secondary. The primary is introducing kids how to socialize, engage and interact with their peers and authority in a respectful and rule based environment.
But that’s not the only part that was relevant here.
The teacher / instructor has a responsibility to make that happen. The skill is both on the side of the people who have trouble integrating and on the groups to be accepting (or tolerating) them.
Jobs aren’t spaces where you always get to pick your friends as coworkers.
If this was about a foreigner with the wrong skin color or who has a funny accent, we wouldn’t even be having this exchange.
Directions not clear, accidentally done almost every assignment by myself
I liked you in my groups, almost as much as the other hated me!
Wouldn’t it be better to reinforce this at a younger age and let people explore their individuality as they grew older?
The issue with that is that then group work seems “childish” while individuality seems more “mature”, and then you’re just breeding rugged individualism which isn’t great for society at large. You need group work right through your development as you’ll need to work with others in order for society to function well.
I remember fondly one time in uni when the lecturer started describing a group project for the next assessment, picked up on everyone else in the room being very noticeably against the idea, then proceeded to backtrack on that and make it an individual project after all…
I’ll hang my balls in a waffle iron before I do another group project.
Make sure you record it. I haven’t found any pictures or videos of that one, yet.
Fuck. That. Being alone on a project is the fucking DREAM. Either you’re the only competent one doing all the work, or you’re a delusional idiot that thinks they’re helping.
It depends on the project, I remember one I had to do for an Operating Systems class where everyone was basically putting in part time job amount of hours per week for it, the computer lab was packed until 2am consistently just with people doing this project and people who attempted it alone (allowed but explicitly advised against) ended up failing
that sounds great to me? working in groups sucks
Yeah, anon will probably spend less time on this assignment than any of the people in the other groups who do their job instead of just lazing, and they’ll get all the credit for it. The downside being that for many tasks that you’ll encounter at work, doing everything yourself is not an option because work teams often combine people with different qualifications, plus workloads that are impossible do alone. So you kind of need the practice from school/college.
Why would the professor not randomly assign groups?
Because that’s annoying for anyone capable of forming groups.
I agree, but are a student’s preferences the only contributing factor?
I expect the professor lets them decide groups then throws the stragglers like Anon into the smaller groups
Believe it or not, this guy is gonna commit an insurrection for a rapist pedophile republican in a couple years because of this
Teacher in college?
Nobody ever listened to me when I did group projects in school anyway. No matter how many times I turned out to be right
If you ever needed an example of why group projects suck… Well here you go.
And this is just the tip. The worst is the combination of idiocy, laziness, and sociopathy you get to work with.
Well, shit, now I’ve gone and given multiple reasons why group projects are great practice.











