- cross-posted to:
- privacy@lemmy.world
- cross-posted to:
- privacy@lemmy.world
The UK’s Investigatory Powers Tribunal has confirmed that the UK government served Apple with a secret Technical Capability Notice. Thank you for being a Ghacks reader.
Seems to me it says that UK government can compel apple to provide data from devices belonging to UK customers.
iOS should be regarded as insecure. If one party can get the data, so can others.
From what I read it doesn’t sound like a backdoor but rather them simply turning off the option for E2EE. I think a backdoor would be worst, not sure
Without e2ee, apple have the keys. With e2ee, the user has the keys. It’s not a backdoor per se, but apple do have access and can therefore turn over content if compelled by authorities. To my earlier point, if one party (in this case apple) has access, then others could gain access.
The fact the conversation exists indicates they have probably have turned over data in the past and UK Gov didnt want to lose that access route.
the UK asked apple to give them a backfired to their advanced protection system (E2E encryption of icloud data). since apple could not legally refuse they disabled the feature for everyone (and putting the UK government in evidence)
If they served this order to Apple, I guarantee they served it to Google as well.
Perhaps, but i’d have my doubts they even needed to serve an order to google.
The order looks to have resulted in withdrawal of iCloud e2ee for UK. Google dont offer e2ee so are probably in no danger of being unable to comply.I really hate that we have to deal with these big centralised attack targets from monopolist services, when there is the technical capability for federated alternative technologies that offer more natural potential for data sovereignty, privacy, and security
Am I understanding correctly that this gives law enforcement more accessibility to information on apple devices or am I dim?
Basically the UK tried to tell Apple to put a backdoor in their end to end encryption for data stored on cloud. They said no, and instead disabled end to end encryption for British users. They are still requesting more data into British users, but they’re not allowed to say what the notice is. This is literally just the fight to tell British people what the government is demanding
So if you’re British, you cannot use Apple’s iCloud for end to end encrypted storage. It should be noted that’s not an option at all for Google’s services, so this isn’t some “Apple bad Google is good” tribal thing. Everybody should want privacy end encryption capabilities to be protected. But really no matter what the only way to ensure your data is truly secure is to use a hardened os like graphene and own your entire stack fully encrypted end to end.
The fight began in early 2025. The Home Office ordered Apple to break the encryption on iCloud Advanced Data Protection, the setting that locks a user’s photos and backups so tightly that not even Apple can read them. That order reached beyond Britain to users worldwide, Americans included.
Rather than build the backdoor, Apple switched the feature off for UK users in February 2025.
Last August, Britain dropped the demand for Americans’ data. It did not drop the demand itself. It reissued the notice, aimed this time only at UK users, and that narrower order is what Apple is now challenging
The secrecy is the fight. The government issues these notices in the dark and argues them in a closed court. Neither side may confirm the details.
Technically they did not say no.
Technically they said there was no way to do it that still allowed it to be secure, so they disabled E2E encryption entirely and cited the UK gov as the reason without technically specifying what the order said.
The only possible way to go IMO. It officially shifted the responsibility to the UK Gov and prevented what they actually wanted: backdoor access the public doesn’t know about, the most dangerous kind. All UK Apple users (or at least everyone who followed the news) were very publicly made aware of these facts through this move.
no. this was about cloud storage







