If the defense for a NK-style society is that it “at least benefits the working class” I suppose even trickle-down isn’t that bad… whether class exists as a concept or not means nothing if you have to live like in NK…
The truth is that as long as you have a structure that allows a group of people to control and steer society - be it a “Proletarian dictatorship designed to benefit the workers” or otherwise - those people are gonna shape it in a way where it benefits themselves. It’s a reasonable assessment that the main issue of the Soviet Union was Stalin’s insanity and forcing certain policies (collectivisation) too fast, but the truth of the matter is that a new class simply emerged: the political, the ones that might not be traditionally rich but benefit in other ways. The working class was never the main beneficiary of the Soviet Union… at the end of a day a dictatorship is just a dictatorship and it’s never for the people. I’m in no way against socialism or enacting various socialist or socialist-adjacent fiscal policies but that doesn’t mean that all just magically become good when the working class dubiously “benefits”.
And how much has those same parameters improved in capitalist societies? China didn’t become rich and influential until they started transitioning into s capitalist class society. No shit that working class conditions improved compared to (almost) literally being serfs





I’m saying that I’d take even a full on trickle-down society if NK is a good society to you solely based on the “working class being more equal”.
It absolutely is. Even before he went full on paranoid tens of millions of people starved to death because it was more important to collectivise just for the sake of it rather than taking a pragmatic approach to transition. But hey, that’s okay because the working class had more power, right? No one ever has “absolute” power; Stalin was way more powerful than anyone should ever argue for. Hitler also improved the economy of Germany, are we gonna praise him now? And Stalin, the dude that you apparently love, did help defeat the Nazis by sacrificing 20 million young men and being lucky with the weather. But that’s surely due to Soviet socialism being great, right?
It is absolutely not absurd to talk of a political class. When a certain group of people get the best houses, the best food, the dachas, the best security, access to the secret phones, yes you have a damn political class… I have a realistic view of socialism. You have an insanely rose-tinted view of evil regimes that were never the type of socialist they should’ve been.
Please, China is out-capitalisming basically every capitalist society. They’re built up around amassing personal wealth and mass consumption. There’s literally nothing socialist about modern-day China except that they have a so-called “dictatorship of the proletariat”. And by that I don’t mean that it’s a bad country - it’s thriving more than most Western countries and it’s safe, clean, and well-off in most places.
All in all you have the view of a privileged c*** who read Marx once and thinks they’re cool but have no experience with totalitarian states